IR34 29 November 1994 TAX AVOIDANCE - MANIPULATION OF PRICE OF STOCK WHEN IT IS SOLD OR TRANSFERRED FOR VALUABLE CONSIDERATION AT THE CESSATION OF A TRADE The Chancellor proposes in his Budget to amend the rules on the valuation of stock when a trade is discontinued and sold or transferred to a connected person. The Chancellor's intention is to counter avoidance of tax by enabling an artificial price placed on the stock in these circumstances to be over-ridden for tax purposes. The change will take effect in any case where a trade is discontinued on or after today. It is estimated that the measure will yield Pounds 20 million in the tax year 1996-97. DETAILS 1. At present, when a business is discontinued and its stock in trade is sold to another trader the price of the stock agreed between the parties is regarded as a trading receipt of one and a trading expense of the other, whatever the value of that stock. 2. Where the parties are connected with one another (for example, by means of a family or proprietorial link) the price of the stock is sometimes manipulated to produce an advantageous overall tax result. Typically the stock is sold at undervalue to create losses to carry back against profits in earlier years or to defer the tax liability by transferring it to the purchaser. But occasionally the stock is sold at overvalue to create a profit to absorb earlier trading losses of the vendor and effectively to pass on losses to the purchaser. 3. Subject to the option described below, the value of the stock transferred between connected persons on the discontinuance of a trade will be taken to be the amount which would have been realised if the sale or transfer of the stock had taken place in an arm's length transaction. This change will take effect in any case where a trade is discontinued on or after today. 4. There may be circumstances where the arm's length rule would impose tax on potentially substantial unrealised profits even though no tax advantage was sought. It is therefore proposed that, where the arm's length value of the stock exceeds both a. the actual sale price and, b. its carrying value for tax purposes, being the amount which would be taken into account as representing the cost of the stock if it were to be sold in the ordinary course of the trade the parties may make a joint election to substitute the greater of (a) or (b) for the arm's length value. NOTES FOR EDITORS 2. Section 101(1)(a) of the Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1988 provides that the amount realised on the sale or the value of consideration given for stock transferred when a trade is discontinued will be treated as a trading receipt of the business which is ceasing, and the same value will be used as the cost of the stock of the business purchasing the stock. 2. It was introduced in 1938 to ensure that a trader who had stock which had appreciated in value since its acquisition did not escape paying tax on the profits represented by that growth in value by arranging for a disposal of the whole business. It is now, itself, being used to avoid or defer tax, by manipulation of the price agreed between connected parties.