2 The Budget Measures
2.01 Chapter 1 describes the Government's overall approach to economic policy. This chapter summarises and explains the specific tax, national insurance contributions and spending measures announced in the Budget[1] and relates them to the key policy aims listed in paragraph 1.04.
2.02 Chapter 1 also describes the key principles that will underpin the tax system: fairness, and a tax system which is seen to be fair, encouraging employment opportunities and work incentives for all, and promoting savings and long-term investment. This Budget will make a start in meeting these objectives.
Promoting economic stability
2.03 In order to encourage stability in the housing market and balanced economic growth the Budget:
- reduces mortgage tax relief from 15 per cent to 10 per cent with effect from 6 April 1998. Relief will remain at the basic rate for those aged 65 and over who take out a loan to buy a life annuity (1); and
- increases the rate of stamp duty on transfers of property (except shares) from 1 per cent to 1 1/2 per cent if the price is more than £250,000, or to 2 per cent if the price is more than £500,000. The new rates will apply from 8 July, except where the transfer is made in pursuance of a contract made on or before 2 July (2).
Encouraging long-term investment
2.04 The Budget builds on the work of the corporate tax review the Government carried out whilst in Opposition and which has continued into Government.
Companies and shareholders
2.05 The Budget contains major changes to corporation tax. The Government's objective is to create an improved climate for long term investment. To achieve this objective, the following measures are proposed:
- reduction in the main corporation tax rate - the main rate of corporation tax will be reduced from 33 per cent to 31 per cent from 1April 1997, enhancing the UK's position as the major industrialised country with the lowest corporate tax rate, 50,000 companies will benefit (3).
- reduction in the small companies' rate - the small companies' rate of corporation tax will be reduced from 23 per cent to 21 per cent from 1April 1997, 400,000 companies will benefit (4).
- abolition of payments of tax credits (5):
- payment of tax credits to pension schemes and UK companies (other than charitable companies) will be abolished for dividends paid on or after Budget day;
- other shareholders will generally not be affected by changes to tax credits until 6April 1999, when tax credits will normally no longer be payable to other shareholders with no tax liability;
- the rate of tax credits will halve to 10 per cent from April 1999. No individual shareholder paying tax at the lower, basic, or higher rates on all his or her dividends will face a higher income tax bill as a result of the changes, because dividend income within the lower or basic rate bands will be taxed at 10 per cent and higher rate income at 32.5 per cent (the halving of the rate of tax credits to 10 per cent reduces the amount of gross dividend income, so the 22.5 per cent extra tax payable at the higher rate is equivalent to the 20 per cent extra payable under the existing system);
- the April 1999 change is timed to fit with the introduction of individual savings accounts which will be available for holders of TESSAs and PEPs as well as other individual shareholders and savers;
- transitional relief for charities will be available from April 1999 through public expenditure over a five year period.
- advance corporation tax - will continue to be paid by companies at the same rate as now.
- abolition of foreign income dividends from April 1999 - with the exception of the arrangements for international holding companies, the special rules for foreign income dividends will cease to apply from 6 April 1999. The change will protect the Exchequer yield of advance corporation tax once the abolition of payable tax credits has made shareholders indifferent whether they receive an ordinary dividend (which currently carries a payable tax credit) or a foreign income dividend (which does not)(6).
- temporary doubling of capital allowances for small and medium enterprises' plant and machinery - expenditure on plant and machinery by small and medium sized enterprises for 12 months after Budget day will qualify for a first year allowance at double the previous rate of writing down allowance, that is at 50 per cent, or 12 per cent if the long-life asset rules apply (7).
- restriction of loss carry back to one year - the period for which a company can carry back trading losses and certain other reliefs will be reduced from three years to one year, except for losses made in the 12months before a trade ceases. This reverses a change introduced in 1991 at the depth of the recession (8).
The film industry
2.06 To stimulate the production of British films and thereby promote employment, investment and opportunities in the film industry, the Budget will introduce:
- 100 per cent write-off for production and acquisition expenditure incurred after Budget day on British qualifying films costing £15 million or less to make and completed in a period of three years from Budget day (9).
Modernising the welfare state
Welfare to Work
2.07 The Budget introduces the Government's Welfare to Work programme, to attack youth and long-term unemployment and the low levels of employment among lone parents, and break the spiral of escalating spending on social security. A total of £5.2 billion will be invested in this programme.
- From January 1998, in 10-15 pathfinder areas, and from April 1998 nationally, the New Deal for young people will help those aged under 25 who have been unemployed for more than six months through four routes from welfare into work. The programme is described in more detail in the box on page 31.
- In a New Deal for the long-term unemployed, from June 1998 businesses will be offered a subsidy of £75 a week for six months if they employ anyone who has been unemployed for a period of two years or more. This will help business cover the increased costs it faces while the new employee's work skills are being upgraded. The Government will also reform the "16 hour" rule to help this group access full-time training and education where it improves their employability.
- Lone parents whose youngest child is in the second term of full-time school will be offered help with job search, training, re-skilling and if necessary childcare. The programme will be voluntary and will be delivered by designated Employment Service caseworkers. The Government's approach will be demonstrated in eight areas starting in July 1997, and will be available nationally from October 1998. The programme will be supported, as part of the Government's national childcare strategy, by extra help with childcare costs within Family Credit, Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit; by the use of lottery money to deliver after-school clubs; and by 50,000 new places for trainee child carers taken on under the New Deal for the unemployed.
Welfare to Work - a New Deal for the young unemployed
The New Deal for the young unemployed will begin in around 10 per cent of the country in January 1998. It will start nationally in April 1998. It will be delivered by the Employment Service, in partnership with a wide range of other government agencies and departments, and with the private and voluntary sectors. For each young person, the programme will start with a gateway period of careers advice and intensive help with looking for work, and with training in the skills required as entrants to the world of work. Young people will be helped towards the New Deal option that best suits their needs. Throughout the whole process they will be supported by a designated caseworker. As young people near the end of their option, further help and support will be provided to help them stay in work. Extra help will be focused on those with most disadvantages.
The employer option
Many young people will find they can move straight from welfare into a job. To encourage employers to play their part, the Government will offer a £60 a week subsidy payable for up to six months. The payment will be made with the minimum of bureaucracy, and will be accompanied by a national effort to engage the business community. In addition, £750 per person has been allocated to finance training towards accredited qualifications.
Full-time education or training
For some young people the most appropriate option will be full-time training in skills up to NVQ level 2. The method will vary from on-the-job training in vocational skills to a course at the local college. In each case the emphasis will be on improving employability. For this programme, the Government will reform the “"16 hours study rule”" which has prevented unemployed people from accessing full-time education and training.
A job with the voluntary sector
Voluntary organisations will be invited to come forward with innovative ideas to provide young people with the work experience and skills that will help improve their employability. The placement must have a training element. The Government is looking in particular for placements that help meet other social and economic objectives, for example tackling the causes of crime. Particular emphasis will be placed on voluntary sector placements to provide 50,000 new trained childcarers to support other aspects of the Welfare to Work programme.
The Environmental Task Force
The aim of the new Environmental Task Force will be to improve the employability of young people through projects of benefit to the whole community, including projects to help meet the Government's target for heat conservation and efficiency. It will be delivered by a wide variety of private and voluntary sector providers. Again, training for accredited qualifications will be an important element.
Under the New Deal, rights need to be balanced by responsibilities. Benefit sanctions will apply to young people who refuse an offer of help.
- While there is a pressing need to target spending on the problems of the existing young and long-term unemployed, a root of the unemployment problem lies in under-achievement at school. The New Deal for schools will start to tackle the run-down infrastructure of schools, so that youngsters will be educated in schools fit for the twenty first century, not the nineteenth. It will also cover IT equipment to equip school leavers with technology skills. In order to benefit, individual schools will have to commit themselves to improved performance.
2.08 For the programmes for the unemployed to be successful in breaking the cycle of despair, an enthusiastic response from employers and the voluntary sector will be essential. A task force, headed by Sir Peter Davis, Chief Executive of the Prudential Group, has been established to advise on the development of the programme and monitor its effectiveness.
2.09 These programmes are a first step. The Government aims to extend the approach adopted on behalf of the young and long-term unemployed and lone parents to other groups excluded from the labour market, including people on Incapacity Benefit. The Government also plans to improve skills and employability through a new University for Industry. Detailed proposals will be announced in due course. Provision has also been made within the resources provided by the windfall tax for future initiatives in support of the Welfare to Work strategy.
Windfall tax
2.10 The Welfare to Work programme will be funded by aone-off tax on the excess profits of the privatised utilities. The tax will apply to companies, privatised by flotation, and subject to economic regulation under specified Acts.
2.11 A company's windfall tax liability will be assessed as a proportion of the difference between the value placed on the company at the time of sale and a valuation figure derived by applying a single price-earnings ratio of 9 to its average annual post-tax profits for normally four full accounting years following privatisation.
2.12 The tax will be charged at a rate of 23 per cent. It will be paid in two instalments due on 1 December 1997 and 1 December 1998. Table 2.1 shows the profile of receipts from the tax, compared with the expected spending.
2.13 The yield from the windfall tax will be about £5.2 billion. Taking into account the change to the gas levy (see paragraph 2.30), which the Government considered appropriate in part because of its impact on Centrica, the yield of the two measures to the Exchequer is some £4.8 billion over the next three years.
Table 2.1 Financing Welfare to Work(1)
| £ million |
| 1997-98 | 1998-99 | 1999-00 | 2000-01 | 2001-02 | 1997-02
|
| Spending by programme:(2),(3) |
| A New Deal for young people | 100 | 700 | 830 | 770 | 740 | 3 150 |
| A New Deal for the long term unemployed | 0 | 100 | 80 | 80 | 80 | 350
|
| Sub-total | 100 | 800 | 910 | 850 | 830 | 3 500 |
| of which - initially allocated to departments | 100 | 700 | 800 | 700 | 700 | 3 000 |
| - unallocated | | | | | | 500 |
| |
| A New Deal for Lone Parents(4) | 0 | 40 | 50 | 60 | 60 | 200 |
| A New Deal for Schools | 100 | 300 | 300 | 300 | 300 | 1 300 |
| Provision for Future Measures(5) | 0 | 50 | 50 | 50 | 50 | 200
|
| Total expenditure | 200 | 1 180 | 1 310 | 1 260 | 1 240 | 5 200 |
| Windfall tax(6) | 2 600 | 2 600 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 5 200
|
| 1 The spending in this table, financed by the windfall tax, is outside the Control Total, see Table 2.4.
2 Illustrative levels of spending based on current levels of unemployment. Actual provision for any particular year will be decided in the light of the number of eligible people and the effectiveness of the programme.
3 Departmental breakdown of spending on the basis of these illustrative figures would be:
|
| Department for Education and Employment | 160 | 900 | 1 010 | 920 | 920 | 3 900 |
| Department of Social Security | 20 | 50 | 50 | 60 | 60 | 240 |
| Scottish Office | 10 | 30 | 30 | 30 | 30 | 120 |
| Welsh Office | 0 | 20 | 20 | 20 | 20 | 60 |
| Northern Ireland | 10 | 40 | 40 | 40 | 40 | 180
|
| 4 Plus extra help with child care through Family Credit and other in-work benefits.
5 Including the University for Industry and Welfare to Work help for people on Incapacity Benefit.
6 Forecast receipts.
|
2.14 The windfall tax will be complemented by a forward-looking review of utility regulation which will seek to ensure a long-term stable framework of regulation for the utilities, one which adequately protects consumers and provides the right incentives for the firms themselves. Any proposals from the review which have implications for companies will be introduced only after the windfall tax instalments are paid.
Individual Learning Accounts
2.15 ILAs could provide individuals with the incentive to invest in training to gain the skills they want. One model for an ILA would be a savings account dedicated to training with special rules controlling payments in and withdrawals. The Government will launch a consultation process for employers and other interested parties. Issues include what the rules should be, what sort of training should be covered and what incentives would be justified.
Moving towards a fairer tax system
VAT on fuel and power
2.16 One of the Government's key election pledges was to reduce the 8 per cent rate of VAT on fuel and power to 5 per cent, the lowest level allowed under European Community law. This will come into effect on 1 September 1997 in time for domestic, charity non-business and small-scale business users to get the benefit of the lower rate in their bills for the winter period (11).
2.17 The change will cost £220 million in 1997-98 and £485 million in the first full year (1998-99). To pay for it, the Budget contains the following tax changes, which are also designed to improve the fairness of the tax system.
Private medical insurance
2.18Tax relief on premiums for private medical insurance for the over 60s, which is received by about 1/3 million people, is to be withdrawn in respect of contracts taken out on or after Budget day. Premiums on pre-Budget day annual contracts will continue to qualify for relief until these contracts come to an end and in certain circumstances relief will be given to those who have not finalised contracts by Budget day (12).
Anti-avoidance measures
2.19 The Budget contains the following measures designed to secure the tax base and combat avoidance by blocking tax loopholes and restricting the use of special reliefs:
Corporation tax
- taxing dividends on trading assets as trading profits - from Budget day, include dividend income as part of the holder's trading profits when shares are held as trading assets rather than investments (13).
- Finance Leasing: acceleration of capital allowances - from Budget day, prevent acceleration of capital allowances on machinery and plant through the use of finance leases and subsidiaries with different year ends(14).
- Finance Leasing: sale and leaseback, transfers of unused past allowances - prevent the sale of unused capital allowances through the sale of machinery and plant and finance leaseback on or after Budget day(15).
- "Company Purchase schemes" - from Budget day when a company is sold to avoid paying corporation tax liabilities, the Inland Revenue will be able to collect the unpaid tax from the previous owners of the company, or from other companies previously in the same group. This reinforces a similar measure in the 1994 Finance Act. The legislation will be included in the 1998 Finance Bill (16).
PAYE
- PAYE avoidance (trade debts) - prevent employers from avoiding their obligation to operate PAYE by paying their employees in trade debts. Legislation taking effect from Budget day will be included in the 1998 Finance Bill (17).
VAT
- Second-hand goods margin scheme - restrict the use of the special scheme for accounting for VAT on second-hand goods on the seller's margin, where the goods have been acquired tax-free under the transfer of a going concern provision, from 3 July ($).
- Cash accounting scheme - counter the use of the VAT cash accounting scheme for tax avoidance, from 3 July (18).
- Capital goods scheme - extend the scope of the VAT capital goods scheme to include building refurbishment and fitting out costs and civil engineering works, and to block other potential loopholes, from 3 July ($).
Insurance premium tax
- Health care insurance - reinforce the liability borderline between taxable and exempt health care insurance by applying the 4 per cent insurance premium tax rate to certain long-term health care insurance, from 1October 1997. This will also prevent distortion of trade (19).
Other anti-avoidance measures
2.20 Strengthening tax rules for multinationals - the Government intends to change and modernise the tax rules on transfer pricing and Controlled Foreign Companies in the Finance Bill following the next Budget. The purpose of the changes will be to make the tax provisions more effective, to allow them to be applied more fairly, and to protect UK tax revenue. This will strengthen the legislation and bring it into line with modern practice in other major countries. The Government proposes to publish draft legislation during 1997 and consult on the detail. This will build on existing work and comments already made by taxpayers and their representatives in their responses to consultations carried out by the Inland Revenue under the previous Government, which had itself announced its intention to legislate in these areas.
Protecting the environment and health
2.21 The Government places a high priority on use of the tax system to deliver environmental objectives. Where environmental taxes can make an efficient contribution to a cleaner environment, and where their distributional implications are acceptable, the Government will consider their use.
2.22 In line with this, the Budget includes further announcements:
- work is to be undertaken on the environmental costs associated with the extraction of aggregates and other quarrying. These costs include impacts on landscape, on local residents and effects of noise and dust. Results of this work will feed into consideration of policy measures. They will be considered alongside assessment of the operation and level of the landfill tax;
- the Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions will be issuing, in time to inform the next Budget, a consultation document examining ways of improving water quality, by reducing discharges of pollutants and encouraging greater clean-up. There are a number of policy options, including economic instruments, and consultation will contribute to the choice of measures;
- vehicle excise duty is being indexed in November (see paragraph 2.26 below). The Government also intends to go ahead with the proposal, made by the last administration, to reduce VED by up to £500 for lorries which meet a low emission standard. Details are being worked up following recent completion of consultation. This will encourage the fitting of particulate traps or conversion to gas power. But the existing measure did not go far enough and it will be extended to buses, which also make a significant contribution to harmful urban emissions ($);
- the Government will review the structure of bus fuel duty rebate, including looking at its role in promoting lower emission vehicles;
- the changes to excise duties on fuels (see paragraph 2.24 below) signal the Government's commitment to placing the environment at the core of the tax system by discouraging environmental pollution by road users. The freeze on road fuel gases will give another signal to help encourage conversion of vehicles to use road fuel gases ($);
- the Government has stated that one of its objectives is to help those on low incomes to save energy and will consult on the best means to achieve this. Section 111 of the Finance Act 1997 requires the Treasury to produce a report on the consequences to the Exchequer of VAT relief for energy-saving materials by May 1998. This deadline has now been brought forward to the end of October 1997 and the scope has been extended into a wider consultation exercise which will also look at other options for meeting the objective.
Excise duties
2.23 Tobacco - The Government is committed to increasing tobacco duties on average by at least 5 per cent a year in real terms (compared to the previous Government's 3 per cent commitment) as one measure aimed at reducing tobacco consumption and dissuading young people from starting smoking. From 1December this year, cigarette duty will be increased by approximately 5.2 per cent in real terms, and the duties on cigars and on other smoking tobacco and chewing tobacco will be increased by 5 per cent in real terms. There will be no increase for hand-rolling tobacco (23).
2.24 Fuel duties - The tax (duty plus VAT) on leaded, unleaded and super-unleaded petrol, and diesel, will rise by 4 pence per litre from 6 pm on Budget day(20). The previous Government's commitment to future annual increases averaging at least 5 per cent in real terms will be raised to at least 6 per cent. Also from 6 pm on Budget day, the duties on gas oil and fuel oil will rise by 0.08pence per litre and 0.06 pence per litre respectively (22). The duty on road fuel gases (liquefied petroleum gas and compressed natural gas) will be held at current levels and the duty differential with diesel will be at least maintained for this Parliament.
2.25 Alcohol duties - The duties on all alcoholic drinks will be increased by 3 per cent, in line with inflation, from 1 January 1998 (26).
(1) The effect of the tax and NICs measures on government revenues is set out in Table2.2. The number in brackets after each measure refers to the line in Table2.2 where its yield or cost is shown. The symbol "-" means that the proposal has no effect on revenue. "$" means it has negligible effects on revenue amounting to less than £3million a year. The overall effects of the public expenditure measures on the Control Total and General Government Expenditure are set out in Tables2.3 and 2.4. [Back]
| We welcome your comments on this site.
|
Prepared 2 July 1997 |